I've said this before in some threads but now I'm bringing it up on its own topic.
PEOPLE MAKE MISTAKES its part of being imperfect humans WE DO STUPID SHIT, Everyone has done some stupid shit and fucked up MULTIPLE times but you know what helps us not dwell on our mistakes? Forgiveness and second chances. Where would this world be today if nobody ever got a second chance? think about it.
This community has a tendency to see someone make a mistake and NEVER give them a second chance. Take @Prophet for example, he used to be a minge and was perm banned multiple times, look at him now, he's mature, respectful and serious but nobody sees that, all they see is the mingy prophet. He has now quit the server because nobody gave him a second chance. This attitude needs to stop, people change. Prisoners that have murdered, raped or stolen eventually get a second chance (depending on severity) Why cant this community give people who have fucked up a second chance too. AND YES of all people its me posting this because who else would.
I'm making this reply from not reading the others, they look too long. But here is my tidbit of the whole "situation". It's going to be long, so a tl;dr is in order. Tldr is that sure, people make mistakes, but make enough of them and you'll piss off the wrong people. Saying that, I'll begin.
So, Prophet, I'll agree that he is a very respectful person at his current point, and while it is unfortunate that he has left this community, it is his own fault. Everything he did led up to this point, and if he would've just stopped, we wouldn't be having this conversation, but instead, he continued until he knew he was in deep shit, then attempted to play the victim in the end, which just pissed off more people, you making this thread really isn't helping him at all.
Prophet could've and can still change, as it is apparent with his most recent behavior (before he left the community). Though the damage was well-dealt enough to where only small part of the community actually respected him, because of his previous offenses. Let's take this into a real-life scenario. A man has just stepped out of jail, convicted of murder, rape, and theft, you can't expect him to be instantly welcomed into the world, he has to abandon his past completely and start anew, Prophet attempted to do this by leaving Medics, and going under a new name, but couldn't commit, and so now he has left the community in a fit of anger because he wasn't automatically respected. Going back to the convict, the convict can't just say "I'll never do that again" and instantly gain the trust of others, it takes time, A LOT of time, he just didn't give the community enough time to respect him again.
Also, making this thread is probably just pouring salt into the wound, drawing more and more attention to this "problem" is leading to more problems, more arguments, and more anger toward each other, though skimming over the replies, I notice that they are actually intellectual and instead of biting at each-others throats, people are actually discussing things in a proper manner, which I love personally.
How to fix this "issue"? Let it fix itself until attention is needed toward this kind of topic, it's one person, not five, ten, heck even twenty, it's a single person, and a single problem, which can fix itself by letting time pass, and forgetting about it. If Prophet ever decides to come back, the right decision would be to suck it up and deal with the few people who will still dislike him, because you can't please everyone. The internet is not a safe space full of caring people, it's a wasteland of people trying to escape the world. The only way this could be an actual problem is if people are taking his online behavior as his real-life behavior, people go online to develop a new persona, a new alias, something to hide behind, and of what I see, no one is saying that Prophet is an asshole irl, so this "issue" isn't really an issue, just biased opinions.